Stressed Out:
Dungeness Crabs off the Pacific Northwest Coast
By Sarah Marquis
November 2022
Dungeness crab is an iconic and valuable fishery resource that is culturally and economically important to West Coast communities. Off the coast of Oregon and Washington, tribal, commercial, and recreational fishers pull up crab pots, expecting a haul of Dungeness crabs. Too often lately, what they find are pots filled with dead crabs, suffocated from a lack of oxygen near the seafloor.
Hypoxia—dangerously low oxygen levels—is killing Dungeness crabs off the Pacific Northwest Coast, predominantly during the summer and early fall. Marine animals don’t breathe air, but they still need oxygen, which they absorb from the water. If sufficient oxygen is missing from the water column, the animals may perish.
In addition, blooms of harmful algae have led to the closure of entire Dungeness crab fisheries on the West Coast in past years. Harmful algal blooms are the rapid growth of algae that can produce toxins dangerous to animals and habitats, with potential risk to humans who eat contaminated shellfish.
Multiple Stressors
Hypoxia and harmful algal blooms are considered stressors to the health of Dungeness crabs. Other stressors include ocean acidification, rising ocean temperatures, and marine heatwaves. Each of these stressors is known to harm marine species and ecosystems independently, but scientists are only beginning to unravel the ways in which environmental stressors may interact, and whether there may be unprecedented consequences.
Climate change is already making existing marine environmental stressors worse through changes to temperature, precipitation, seasonal cycles, and ocean chemistry. These changes impact ocean processes and can increase the occurrence, severity, and duration of stressor events. Understanding how multiple stressors may interact and cause cascading impacts to a wide range of marine species and habitats is critical for marine resource management, especially within defined marine areas with fixed boundaries, such as national marine sanctuaries and tribal “usual and accustomed” areas.
Usual and accustomed areas are "all places that a tribe fished prior to signing treaties" and "places adjudicated to have been reserved by one or more tribe(s) for fishing through treaties with the United States."
Collaboration is Key
Resource managers, including tribal co-managers, are preparing for the anticipated impacts of climate change by increasing their understanding as to how multiple stressors are likely to interact and affect marine ecosystems, species, and the communities dependent on them.
“Hypoxia, ocean acidification, harmful algal blooms, and marine heatwaves are already present on the Olympic Coast, and we need to understand how future events are likely to interact and affect resources in the sanctuary in the future,” says Jenny Waddell, research coordinator at Olympic Coast National Marine Sanctuary. “Trends indicate that ocean conditions have worsened in the past two decades, affecting both the living resources and the human communities, including Coastal Treaty Tribes on the Olympic Coast, who depend on them.”
NOAA’s National Centers for Coastal and Ocean Science Competitive Research Program, Climate Program Office, Ocean Acidification Program, and U.S. Integrated Ocean Observing System Office, in partnership with the Office of National Marine Sanctuaries, have announced $4.2 million in funding to support a four-year project. The research outlined is geared towards understanding multi-stressor impacts on marine ecosystems under climate change.
The focus is on two ecologically, economically, and culturally important species: Dungeness crab and krill—tiny crustaceans that are a favorite food of several species of large whales. The new program award involves more than 18 collaborating scientists at eight institutions.
The research project will take place off the coasts of Northern California, Oregon, and Washington, including NOAA’s Olympic Coast National Marine Sanctuary.
“Although Olympic Coast National Marine Sanctuary does not manage fisheries, we work closely with state and tribal fishery managers to understand how changing ocean conditions affect populations of important marine species and habitats,” Waddell says.
Data for Resource Management
Understanding the impacts and relationships among multiple stressors is important, but very little data exists so far. This project will rely on a combination of existing ocean data, ocean models, laboratory experiments, and fisheries management evaluation techniques, and has the potential to shape the future of ocean science and fisheries management in the region.
State and tribal fisheries managers in Washington, Oregon, and Northern California will serve as a management advisory board to help guide the research and implement the results. This will ensure a tight link between the collaborating scientists and the specific agency personnel with management responsibilities for coastal shellfish, including Dungeness crab. Recognizing that tribes have a long history of resource stewardship for and reliance on marine resources, the project also incorporates Traditional Ecological Knowledge gathered through ethnographic interviews of tribal members.
Sarah Marquis is the West Coast/Pacific Islands media coordinator for NOAA's Office of National Marine Sanctuaries